بسم الله الرحمن الرحيمIn the name of God the Merciful
From the most repeated misconceptions about quran christians repeate it that othman RA burned quran and make his quran and corrupt it
Answer
Logical agreements
First that's impossible if he courrpt quran and muslims couldn't know because quran is memorized but most of people so if you changed one character then muslims will know
Second that all companions accept what he did and if what he did "Burning all quran" is bad then you will hear alot of muslims will say that he is wrong but no one refused
Why did he do this
In the hadith you will find that the reason is because there is diffrence between people about quran but why did this happend ?
Quran's chapters didn't revelated whole only verses by verses and prophet muhammad had companions that travels and give message of islam to the people in all world so as an example
might companion give people verses from chapter of quran and leave them after this allah revelate more verses in those chapters and another companion go to another country and give them those chapter what will happen is the first contry will say the other added
more verses and the second will say the other deleted more words
so to avoid all this Othman ra copied a quran which is taken from abu bakr and omar book which is taken from the revelation text which is written by revleation writers and he distrubuted all those books to all countries which contain the whole quran
GOOD BUT WHY HE BURNED THE OTHERS ?
First because all other books of quran is personal effort that person wrote what he here from the prophet muhammad so this companion might travel and verse revelated to prophet muhammad so he wont write it in his book so if he leave this book in the future people
might say this is the whole quran and a great problem will happen
Second Because it's personal efforts so it will contain misspelling
Third Some of those books written by companions contains explaning so if othman ra leave it the people in future will think the explanintion is quran so he burned it to avoid this thing
So what he did is a great job
Additional proves
All the companions agree what he did is true and no one refuse except ibn massoad because he sad because he write those chapters what prophet muhammad said and second because he thought that the new mus haf wont contain this way of reading but when he knew the truth he accept that and burn his book
Most of companions memorize quran so if they found one letter changed in this new book they will know and we will know
Second that all companions accept what he did and if what he did "Burning all quran" is bad then you will hear alot of muslims will say that he is wrong but no one refused
Why did he do this
In the hadith you will find that the reason is because there is diffrence between people about quran but why did this happend ?
Quran's chapters didn't revelated whole only verses by verses and prophet muhammad had companions that travels and give message of islam to the people in all world so as an example
might companion give people verses from chapter of quran and leave them after this allah revelate more verses in those chapters and another companion go to another country and give them those chapter what will happen is the first contry will say the other added
more verses and the second will say the other deleted more words
so to avoid all this Othman ra copied a quran which is taken from abu bakr and omar book which is taken from the revelation text which is written by revleation writers and he distrubuted all those books to all countries which contain the whole quran
GOOD BUT WHY HE BURNED THE OTHERS ?
First because all other books of quran is personal effort that person wrote what he here from the prophet muhammad so this companion might travel and verse revelated to prophet muhammad so he wont write it in his book so if he leave this book in the future people
might say this is the whole quran and a great problem will happen
Second Because it's personal efforts so it will contain misspelling
Third Some of those books written by companions contains explaning so if othman ra leave it the people in future will think the explanintion is quran so he burned it to avoid this thing
So what he did is a great job
Additional proves
All the companions agree what he did is true and no one refuse except ibn massoad because he sad because he write those chapters what prophet muhammad said and second because he thought that the new mus haf wont contain this way of reading but when he knew the truth he accept that and burn his book
Most of companions memorize quran so if they found one letter changed in this new book they will know and we will know
Answered
No comments:
Post a Comment